CHALLENGE
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is congressionally mandated to conduct a review of its long-term strategy and priorities every four years, resulting in the Quadrennial Homeland Security Review (QHSR). ANSER analysts were asked to provide systems assessment support to DHS to conduct the 2014 QHSR. The study included characterization of various risk areas (e.g., terrorism, organized crime, and cybersecurity) to understand key dynamics, current trends, and priorities for action.
APPROACH
One way to conduct this assessment would have been to help each individual office assess their mission area, identify relevant risks, think about current activities and trends, identify gaps, and make recommendations for future strategies. Instead, this study brought together diverse stakeholders from many DHS offices in multiple participatory working group sessions. Stakeholders were asked to collaboratively discuss the risk areas they are responsible for, providing information, experiences, and input. Using CLDs, the study team mapped key variables and relationships associated with each risk area based on the information elicited from participating stakeholders. With additional research, relevant current trends were identified and overlaid over the risk CLDs to anticipate how each risk area may evolve going forward.
Figure 1: CLD characterization of a risk area
KEY INSIGHTS
Several key insights emerged from this exercise that would have otherwise been difficult to obtain:
RESULTS
A participatory CLD mapping process served as a key part of the 2014 QHSR methodology. Insights helped inform DHS’s 2014 QHSR to Congress. The CLDs also formed the foundation for quantitative risk assessment in later stages of the QHSR process.